I’ve been wondering about something ever since I recently started using MySpace more often. I had created an account about 6 months ago to just toy with the site to get a better feel for its flow, functionality, and to really just better understand why it has been such a success. I created the account and just left it, but I deleted the infamous “Tom”, who annoys the hell out of me (and even more when people leave him on their friends list!).

After a bit of time, friends started adding me and getting on my case for not using the site. After a bit of peer pressure from these friends, I realized that I had to actually use the site for THEM, and I had to make it look better than the default template that they used or else I’d look like a dork. Again, peer pressure.

Initially, I had quite a few pains using it. The flow of the site was poorly designed as links were never where you’d expect them to be, and the site was really designed as an after-thought… it was almost as though they designed the site, which then became successful, and they just kept piling more and more on top of it without really stepping back and analyzing the flow of the site and working through the information architecture. I feel over-whelmed trying to figure the site out… there’s way too much scattered and there’s no real organization.

Now, I’m not talking about how poorly designed the user “MySpace” profiles are. I don’t think that needs any speaking to as I think we all know how bad they can get. I am purely talking about the interface and navigation in which, after you’ve logged in, you use to view comments, manage/customize your profile, account, etc.
I couldn’t fathom how a site as poorly designed as MySpace, could be at all successful. There are obviously many factors that came into play for the site’s success, but then a thought dawned on me a little when I was going to update my profile this evening:

Because MySpace itself is so poorly designed, and almost every page looks like a tornado had gone through more than a few times and took us back to the 80’s, people feel comfortable and at home with it. They don’t feel as though they need to worry about font sizes, font colors, number of fonts-types used on a page, whether or not something is readable, whether or not something is making their page blow out of 1024 (1004) pixels resolution, is compatible with certain browsers, is draining your memory like mad or crashing your browser. They don’t care about web standards – it’s all about having a page that you can call your own, being able to post stupid animations and videos… and not have to worry if it doesn’t look right since everyone else has a funky looking page too – and surprisingly, I’m starting to “get it” – and I’m also liking it.

I’ve also been comparing my experiences with MySpace, versus other Social-Networking sites out there. When I use LinkedIn (which I use every day and strongly urge you to use it if you don’t), I believe that the site is one of the most well designed sites out there. I’ve been through just about every page, and completely understand how it is organized, and have even checked out new features, because it’s so well designed. But I don’t feel “at home” with it… it feels more like a site for work and my career, than for play. The same goes for Facebook. I just received two invites on Facebook this morning – one from a friend of mine, and another from a complete stranger. I added them, and just closed the site. Facebook is one of those sites that I use rarely, as I had with MySpace earlier, and only use for others, not for myself. This could of course evolve into me changing my perception of Facebook. Right now, I don’t use the site because for one, I don’t need another social networking site to have to track, and second, I don’t know how to use it yet and am unfamiliar with the benefits of using it.

So, those are my thoughts on MySpace for now.. there’s definitely something about it, and I’m still digging through it. I believe MySpace really helped change the way mainstream users use the web, and because of their success, I believe there will be some very big contenders coming right after them. I have definitely removed MySpace from my status of “Geocities 2.0.”?

This entry was posted on Wednesday, August 1st, 2007 at 7:50 pm and is filed under A thought.... You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.